Thread Number: 41158  /  Tag: Recent Vacuum Cleaners from past 20 years
Adding Sound Insulation to Central Vacuum Motor?
[Down to Last]

Vacuumland's exclusive eBay Watch:
scroll >>> for more items --- [As an eBay Partner, eBay may compensate vacuumland.org if you make a purchase using any link to eBay on this page]
Post# 436719   12/26/2020 at 20:28 (1,216 days old) by vgwpg (Winnipeg, Manitoba)        

Hello, I am currently working on a project. I got a good deal on a VacuMaid P-225 motor pod with a brand new motor. I did not realize how loud they are until the first time I turned it on, and I have to say, I almost jumped to the ceiling in shock. Even for me, who doesn't really mind a loud vacuum, it's way too loud. Since I had an older S1600 housing kicking around, I decided to put the motor and control board from the P-225 pod into the S1600 pod. However, it is still quite loud.
I was wondering if it would be okay to add foam into the motor housing to quiet the motor? Will the motor run too hot? A lot of newer units are heavily lined, so I figure it is okay, but I want to make sure. I also don't know if there's a certain type of foam that will work better than others.

Also, is there a foam that I could put around the motor cooling air exhaust to capture the carbon dust?

I've attached a couple of pictures below, in case it might help.

Thanks!


  Photos...       <              >      Photo 1 of 2         View Full Size
Post# 436727 , Reply# 1   12/27/2020 at 00:34 (1,216 days old) by tolivac (Greenville,NC)        

Keep in mind central vacuum power units were installed in a utility room,garage,or large closet.So they didn't have quiet in mind since the unit was out of the house.It should be safe to line the inside of the motor compartment with sound absorb material.If you were to put it on the motor-make sure the insulation doesn't block motor air cooling intakes.

Post# 436787 , Reply# 2   12/28/2020 at 00:54 (1,215 days old) by MadMan (Chicago, IL, USA)        

madman's profile picture
It's a big tinny metal can. All that thin metal vibrates with the motor, and acts like a giant speaker cone. Isolating the motor from the can would be the best thing. May not be easy, though. Would be simpler to line the inside of the can with foam. Just don't block any ventilation paths.

Post# 436790 , Reply# 3   12/28/2020 at 06:07 (1,215 days old) by tolivac (Greenville,NC)        

Any of the central vacuums I have the motor is mounted on a rubber gasket ring-provide air seal and noise suppression.

Post# 436796 , Reply# 4   12/28/2020 at 10:10 (1,215 days old) by sanitaire (anchorage, alaska)        

does it have the muffler? those help a little.

Post# 436806 , Reply# 5   12/28/2020 at 16:09 (1,215 days old) by vgwpg (Winnipeg, Manitoba)        

Thank you for the replies!
Thank you for your input. I am glad to know that there shouldn't be a problem, prolonging I keep all of the airpaths clear.

Rex, I understand that they weren't designed to be quiet, but my unit is currenly in an unfinished basement, which doubles as a work area, and I personally find it irritating to do any work while the machine is running.

Madman, would the rubber gasket not be enough to isolate the motor from the housing? The motor in this unit is not bolted down, as it just has a metal plate that holds the motor down (it presses on top of the foam gasket at the top of the motor.) What else could be done, while not losing any performance?

Colin, I do not yet have a muffler, but I most certainly will be getting one, as I do find they significantly reduce the noise level, especially for my neigbors.


Post# 436816 , Reply# 6   12/28/2020 at 19:26 (1,214 days old) by Lesinutah (Utah)        
Adding

lesinutah's profile picture
Insulation or foam underneath the. Motor. I'd say a piece of felt under the mounts would work well. That's my two cents maybe madman has a different idea. It's not like I copied his.

Post# 436838 , Reply# 7   12/29/2020 at 11:13 (1,214 days old) by Ultralux88 (Denver, Colorado)        

ultralux88's profile picture
You can line the inside of the motor section of the can with sound insulation. But two things, don’t put any on the motor itself, and DO NOT block the vents in any way! That motor gets hot and you don’t want to be keeping the heat inside there.

Post# 436840 , Reply# 8   12/29/2020 at 11:15 (1,214 days old) by Ultralux88 (Denver, Colorado)        

ultralux88's profile picture
But in all honesty this will never be a terribly quiet machine, and the motor may also be louder than is should be if the motor fans have a lot of filth in them, which is extremely common on these VacuMaids.

Post# 436879 , Reply# 9   12/29/2020 at 21:54 (1,213 days old) by MadMan (Chicago, IL, USA)        

madman's profile picture
It's not really clear to me how the motor is mounted. If there is ANY metal-to-metal attachment of the motor to the housing, it will amplify the noise of the motor considerably. In the picture, it looks like there is a triangular shaped bracket that's missing the bolts to hold it down. Is that what's supposed to hold the motor?

Like Les says, adding pieces of felt between any metal-to-metal motor mounting would help, at least a little.

That big empty cavity where the motor sits, anyway, could be lined with some kind of foam. Acoustic foam is what you want, but in reality, it's kinda pricey when any old foam will do. Next time you see someone throw away a couch, grab the cushions.

As a matter of fact, I'm not sure what the muffler looks like, but you could make that yourself out of a coffee can and a bit of old foam. I've already made two air compressor mufflers like that.


Post# 436888 , Reply# 10   12/29/2020 at 23:00 (1,213 days old) by vgwpg (Winnipeg, Manitoba)        

Hello, and once again, thank you for the replies!
As an update, I went ahead and lined the entire compartnment with foam, and made sure that there was no metal to metal contact, with the foam gasket at the top, and the rubber gasket at the bottom. Unfortunately, it really didn't make much of a difference. To my ears, it sounded more muffled, but according to the decibel meter, it was still reading 90 db, when the other housing had a measurement of 92 db. I don't understand how the new VacuMaid S2600 is only 60 db when it's apparently the same motor.

So I think I will just keep it in the P-225 housing instead. As you say Madman, it it has the 3 bolt holes. In the "SilentPartner" housing, there is no bolts, the motor is simply held down by a metal plate that pushes down on the foam gasket at the top, which is held in place by screws. I feel it doesn't seal the motor as well as it being bolted, so I think I will sacrifice those 2 db for the more secure mounting. I guess the quiet will just have to wait until I can afford my dream vacuum unit.

But if anyone has any other ideas, I'd be happy to hear them!


Post# 436892 , Reply# 11   12/29/2020 at 23:11 (1,213 days old) by Lesinutah (Utah)        
Unhook

lesinutah's profile picture
The motor and pull everything out of the vacuum tube. Get a pole urethane spray foam insulation. You could also spray something similar to think lining.
You could built a box and enclose the vacuum cut out ports and vents. Then at the top of the box vent and a vent at the bottom. Put small fans both sides sucking in cold through the bottom circulating through the top.


Post# 436894 , Reply# 12   12/29/2020 at 23:34 (1,213 days old) by kirbyklekter (Concord,Ca.)        
There is no taming that beast!

But you could invest in a pair of good quality wireless noise cancelling headphones, for while you're working down there or something like the guys out on the tarmac wear at the airport! Just a thought.

Post# 436895 , Reply# 13   12/30/2020 at 00:09 (1,213 days old) by Electroluxxxx (……)        

Considering that this is a 3 stage premier motor, if installed properly with a muffler and vented outside, it would be considerably quieter. I have a vacu flo 360 with this motor installed in our workshop and it’s really not that bad at all.

Post# 436899 , Reply# 14   12/30/2020 at 03:46 (1,213 days old) by MadMan (Chicago, IL, USA)        

madman's profile picture
How does it exhaust, anyway?

Post# 436901 , Reply# 15   12/30/2020 at 06:46 (1,213 days old) by Electroluxxxx (……)        

From the horn on the motor.

Post# 436933 , Reply# 16   12/30/2020 at 23:28 (1,212 days old) by MadMan (Chicago, IL, USA)        

madman's profile picture
Add a muffling device and exhaust it outside.

Post# 436947 , Reply# 17   12/31/2020 at 11:12 (1,212 days old) by Ultralux88 (Denver, Colorado)        

ultralux88's profile picture
I hate being a wet blanket (well sometimes, but not trying to be here) but in all honesty, if you wanted a quiet unit, this one will likely never be able to meet your wants there. Also, this thing will get much louder over time, as these don’t use a filter, it’s a “true cyclonic” unit and all of the fine dust will be passing through the motor. This also means that you cannot run this thing exhausted into your basement or any other part of the house, you absolutely must pipe the exhaust outside of the house. Doing this will completely remove the exhaust noise from the basement, but still put a muffler on the exhaust, as the vent outside will be as loud as the exhaust was in the basement!

Post# 436967 , Reply# 18   12/31/2020 at 18:13 (1,211 days old) by n0oxy (Saint Louis Missouri, United States)        
one of the quietest units

If you're looking for a quiet unit, I would suggest the Drainvac Viper. It's only 58 DB, and that's with no muffler attached. You can have a conversation while you are in the same room. I do have to use ear plugs when I use one of my units, the Galaxie GA-240, it's a 240 volt dual motor unit and it's quite loud. I use concert ear plugs and they work fine to block out most of it.
Mike


CLICK HERE TO GO TO n0oxy's LINK


Post# 436998 , Reply# 19   1/1/2021 at 16:50 (1,211 days old) by vgwpg (Winnipeg, Manitoba)        
Thanks everyone

I think I'll just go with the old fashioned way - using earplugs.

Madman, I do have a muffler. They're only like $10.

Ultralux88, it is vented outside. I would never have a central vacuum and not exhaust it outside, that's one of my favourite features of them!

n0oxy, one day I will get a brand new quiet unit. Unfotunately, I'm not in the market to do that at this point, but then I have something to look forward to!


Post# 438113 , Reply# 20   2/2/2021 at 18:55 (1,178 days old) by Gregvacs28 (U.S.)        

Change out the motor to a flow-thru motor.
They are relatively cheap compared to a bypass motor.
They are considerably quieter.
They are more powerful. You will get better suction.

I recently found a 1500 watt, 650 Air Watt flow through motor NEW for $39.99 from a CV distributor in FLA.

And because you can vent everything thing that comes out of exhaust compartment of the vacuum, you can insulate all of it but the 2" exhaust hole.

With that by-pass motor you can't block the top exhaust and intake and that is left exposed to the air in your home, along with the noise.

My favorite way of sound insulating these cv units is to remove the motor and electronics, fill all holes except the air in and out and the cord hole, make sure all seams are sealed with caulk, then take a piece of thick shag carpet and wrap it around the walls twice, then wrap it in plastic, and cut the 2" exhaust hole.

Then take chicken wire/mesh and fit it against the carpeted walls to be sure the carpet can't collapse and come in contact with the motor.

Do similar for the top and make sure you have weather stripping on the opening edges. You don't want any air leaking out.

Install the motor and connect to the cord. Install the electronics in a separate box that won't be exposed to the heat , vibration, and dust from the vacuum.

Huge difference in noise level. Plus, ANYTHING that comes out of the vacuum, including carbon dust, motor heat, off-gassing, bag dust, and the typical vacuum dust and odors, along with some of the noise.....goes outside via the vent.

If you haven't converted that S1600 to using bags, do it !
Changing an inexpensive bag takes a minute with no dust clouds or filter cleaning hassles.

I recently acquired a New "Old Stock" MD top fill vacuum and before I'd even use it I did the above.

I took pics I should post.



  View Full Size
Post# 438137 , Reply# 21   2/3/2021 at 17:47 (1,178 days old) by panasonicvac (Northern Utah)        
Kieth

panasonicvac's profile picture
There's a reason why true cyclonic units uses a bypass motor. You would need more layers of filtration than converting the cyclonic canister to just using bags if you were to convert a thru-flow motor in a true cyclonic unit. And honestly I don't even know if the author in this thread has a dirt canister for either the P-225 or the S1600. What I would suggest instead is to get a DC800 bagged canister from Vacumaid that uses HEPA filtration. Otherwise that's one of the downfalls that I have seen from thru-flow motors is without extra filtration layers, the bearings and the motor itself can go bad quicker. Another thing too that I have found is the thru-flow motors do run much hotter than bypass motors.

Post# 438152 , Reply# 22   2/4/2021 at 00:17 (1,177 days old) by gregvacs28 (U.S.)        
Completely agree

"...downfalls that I have seen from thru-flow motors is without extra filtration layers, the bearings and the motor itself can go bad quicker."

Totally agree!
By-pass motors are best for using with carpet cleaning systems, where water or water vapor is possible
or
with cyclonic central vacs where heavier than usual amounts of dirt may be present in the air.

Why they would put a by-pass motor in a typical central vacuum is just expensive and noisy overkill. But then motors have really improved in the last 20 years.

I used to think cyclonic was the cats meow and so "natural"
but soon learned through experience that the difficulty of cleaning out the container with all the dust particles becoming air born
and then having to clean filters and that dust becoming airbourn
and the time it takes for all the pieces to dry....

Bags are simple to change. Takes less than minute and no mess. And a typical CV bag is less than $2.

Flo-thru motors may run hotter. I can't really speak to that. It depends on where one is taking the temperature.
But one thing is for sure, with a vented CV and a flo-thru motor all the heat gets pushed outside.
With a by-pass motor the heat stays in the house because none of the motors workings are vented outside, only the exhaust from the fan. Also carbon dust, off-gassing, and motor noise stays in the house as well.


Post# 438154 , Reply# 23   2/4/2021 at 02:50 (1,177 days old) by panasonicvac (Northern Utah)        

panasonicvac's profile picture
One of the beauties with a true cyclonic unit is there are no filters to ever have buy, clean, or replace. And because they are required to be vented outside, you don't have to worry about all the dust and dirt that you would suck up being blown back indoors. I mean sure it's not like maintaining a bagged unit but I have found that if you use a trash bag to wrap around the unit to clean the debris off the screen like you would with a dryer lint trap. Then use that same trash bag to wrap around the canister tightly to empty it, let the dust settle down for a minute or so while the bag is still sealed onto the canister, seal the trash bag completely afterwards, and throw it away. I barely would get any dust on my hands. Another thing that I have found with Vacuflo's true cyclonic units is the screens doesn't get clogged as much compared to Vacumaid's. In all on honesty, I wouldn't hesitate to put in either a Vacuflo 566Q or a Vacuflo 760 in my own house if I wanted to go for a bagless unit.

I have an uncle who owns a MD Flo-Master F650t that uses a thru-flow motor and it uses a bag that costs like $10 per piece. I can confirm that it does get hot while running. But it is just as quiet as a top of the line MD SilentMaster S5 that uses "two" bypass motors. I don't believe all thru-flow motors are quieter than bypass motors. And who says you can't vent out a central vac that uses a bypass motor? I've seen plenty myself that do. Anyways, those are my two cents here. On a side note, Cana-Vac uses both types of motors for their units and they prefer bypass themselves.

canavac.com/central-vacuum-motors...


  View Full Size
Post# 438926 , Reply# 24   2/19/2021 at 17:15 (1,162 days old) by vgwpg (Winnipeg, Manitoba)        

Hello again,
I do have a cyclonic dirt canister, the VacuMaid DC1200. Therefore, as Panasonicvac mentioned, changing to a flow thru motor would not be possible, due to the amount of dirt passing htorugh the motor.
However, even if I didn't have a cyclonic unit, I would not get a flow thru motor. I do agree that they are quieter, cheaper, and far more powerful for their size, but I also find that they are less durable, and run hotter. As this is the vacuum cleaner that is used every day, I want something that I know will be running strong for years to come. I also do a lot of detail work, so I am not sure the amount of air a flow thru motor would be getting while cleaning carpet with a crevice nozzle is adequate for cooling.

I also haven't had a problem with emptying the canister yet. Personally, I find it far easier to clean out than the Canavac unit I used to have (It had a Beam style filter), and the screen at the top is easy to clean. Unfortunately, it does get clogged quite easily, but it's pretty quick to vacuum it off.
To be honest, I am not sure how I would feel about a bagged power unit. As I mentioned before, it is the main vacuum in the house, and it gets used for everything. For one, I'm not the only one using it, and stuff often gets accidentally sucked up, and it's much easier to be able to retrieve the object from the top of the dirt. I also have rabbits, and their hay and fur fill up the canister quite quickly. The MD style bagged units are very difficult to get where I am, never mind the bags. It's almost all Beam style, filtered cyclonic, or true cyclonic. If I got a new unit, I would probably still use the cyclonic separator as a pre-separator. But I do really like how clean the bagged units are to empty.


Post# 438930 , Reply# 25   2/19/2021 at 19:14 (1,161 days old) by gregvacs28 (U.S.)        

Well you are in Canada.  Canadians have many more homes with CVs than us pitiful people in the U.S.  It's just one of the aspects that makes Canada a desirable country.  People speaking fluet English is another positive attribute.

 

Surely there are distributors there that would be knowledgeable and even have display units that would help you get what's best for you.  


Post# 438937 , Reply# 26   2/20/2021 at 02:48 (1,161 days old) by panasonicvac (Northern Utah)        

panasonicvac's profile picture
I think Canada assembles one of the finest power units on the market. I really like Cyclovac. If I were to pass on getting an American made MD, Cyclovac would be my next choice to get. They have one of the best warranties in the industry! However I will have to admit, I'm impressed with the motors used on Drainvac. I think you could possibly get away with using some units that has a thru-flow motor if you switch from using bagged to bagless. But I think getting a cyclonic dirt canister for a bagged unit or just a true cyclonic unit would still be a better option to have. Cyclovac sells a cyclonic dirt canister and possibly ACV (All Canada Vac), the Canadian version of Vacumaid.


Forum Index:       Other Forums:                      



Comes to the Rescue!

Woops, Time to Check the Bag!!!
Either you need to change your vacuum bag or you forgot to LOG-IN?

Discuss-O-MAT Log-In



New Members
Click Here To Sign Up.



                     


automaticwasher.org home
Discuss-o-Mat Forums
Vintage Brochures, Service and Owners Manuals
Fun Vintage Washer Ephemera
See It Wash!
Video Downloads
Audio Downloads
Picture of the Day
Patent of the Day
Photos of our Collections
The Old Aberdeen Farm
Vintage Service Manuals
Vintage washer/dryer/dishwasher to sell?
Technical/service questions?
Looking for Parts?
Website related questions?
Digital Millennium Copyright Act Policy
Our Privacy Policy