Thread Number: 37354  /  Tag: Brand New Vacuum Cleaners
Are canister vacuums in terminal decline?
[Down to Last]

Vacuumland's exclusive eBay Watch:
scroll >>> for more items --- [As an eBay Partner, eBay may compensate vacuumland.org if you make a purchase using any link to eBay on this page]
Post# 398569   9/22/2018 at 08:13 (2,041 days old) by electromatik (Taylorsville, North Carolina, U.S.A.)        

As a person who really loves canister machines, I have been surprised when shopping around. It seems many manufacturers are stripping down their lineups and offering fewer features and models than ever before. It is getting harder and harder to find a company that makes machines with all the high-end features. I want the convenience features but they are not offered much anymore.

Some examples include:
*Tacony has discontinued all the full size models and now offers no machine with full handle controls for motor and motor speed.
*Sebo offers no models with headlight, no power nozzle control on handle, and no parking slot for power nozzle.
*Miele offers no parking slot for power nozzle, ludicrous tools, and short hoses/cords.

It seems our choices for true high-end machines are getting slimmer and slimmer.


Post# 398572 , Reply# 1   9/22/2018 at 08:48 (2,041 days old) by dysonman1 (the county)        

dysonman1's profile picture
Less than 5% of all vacuums sold in the USA are canisters. However, worldwide the number of canisters is more than 90% of all sales. Most of the world has no carpet, or very little.


Post# 398575 , Reply# 2   9/22/2018 at 09:06 (2,041 days old) by fan-of-fans (USA)        

fan-of-fans's profile picture
Yep, definitely. Even more so in the big box brands. Try going into Walmart, Target or Bed Bath and Beyond and find a canister. You might find one, tiny bagless model amidst the uprights.

It's sad, and I know everyone says "Sears is not on my radar anymore, blah blah" but if you want a store where you can find a canister that's not a tiny bagless, and has controls on the handle, Sears is where you will still find it.


Post# 398582 , Reply# 3   9/22/2018 at 10:06 (2,041 days old) by gregvacs28 (U.S.)        
Most vacuum store


I knew as a child have closed. The ones that are still open don't look the same. They don't have any used vacuums for sale any more. Most stuff they do have is an upright. Their money is made selling bags and belts and a making a slim margin on throw-away vac.

Then there is market saturation.

I wonder though, if central vacuums are taking up some of the canister sales volume.



  View Full Size
Post# 398586 , Reply# 4   9/22/2018 at 10:30 (2,041 days old) by JustJunque (Western MA)        

justjunque's profile picture
Honestly, I rarely even look at the new offerings when I go to a store.
I stopped briefly at the Aerus booth at our New England states fair that's currently going on.
Didn't really look at the new ones, although they do look nice.
And I like that there's still brand new models that are nearly identical to my Epic 6500, and Ambassador III.
I chatted briefly with one of the reps about the older machines.
He seemed somewhat amused by the fact that I have four Electroluxes, and asked, jokingly, if I was starting a museum.
He did seem pretty knowledgeable about the timeline of E-lux models.

Since we have no carpet, and only a few area rugs, I use in rotation, one of the three working E-luxes, or the Hoover Portable.
If I'm feeling like a little variety, I'll pull out a Hoover Convertible to use on the area rugs.

I need to make that decision soon actually.
The wife is sick in bed today, so I'm currently in the process of doing a bunch of laundry, and vacuuming needs to happen.
The weather is in the 60s right now, with low humidity, and a breeze.
So the air conditioners are getting a much needed break, and the windows are open.
Perfect cleaning weather!

Barry


Post# 398594 , Reply# 5   9/22/2018 at 12:16 (2,041 days old) by n0oxy (Saint Louis Missouri, United States)        
canisters

I'm also a big canister person, I actually don't like uprights. I like to use a pull around canister, central vacuum or backpack.
It's actually surprising that canisters are not more popular here. They are really more flexible than uprights. With a power nozzle canister you can clean your carpets as good as an upright and easily switch over to cleaning hard floors or above the floors. And there are so many attachments that you can add even if they did not come with it. Most uprights simply do not have those capabilities.
I think the reason Tacony discontinued their full sized canisters is because the Prima and Wonder fill the canister market. They are available as a straight suction model or with a few different power nozzles. It's a good thing that the controls are not in the hose, that's just more circuit boards that can fail and it's really not necessary.
If you want a good canister now you would need to consider Tacony, Miele, Sebo, or Aerus. Electrolux also makes the ultra one canisters which are very good. And let's not forget the Numatic line. Good canisters are available but you won't find them in your big box store, you will have to get them on line or through a vacuum dealer.
I'm also a big fan of central vacuums, especially using them free standing without pipes, very powerful, and let's not forget the backpacks, you can clean really fast with those.
Mike


Post# 398596 , Reply# 6   9/22/2018 at 13:05 (2,041 days old) by completenutt (West Hollywood, California)        
What's old is new again.

completenutt's profile picture

I hope canisters to regain their market share here someday, perhaps someday sooner than later. 

 

I work in property management and most all renovations everyone is doing include removing wall to wall carpeting and putting in laminate or wood type planking (it's new, not my favorite as it's a faux wood appearance/textured vinyl).  Wood or wood type flooring is more popular now, and many people believe not only is it easier to keep clean but lowers general toxins in the air.. formaldehyde, etc.

 

So maybe over time people will rediscover the efficiency of using a canister for cleaning both hard and soft surfaces.  I agree that they are more easily used when switching out tools on the fly to keep cleaning furniture, etc. and are less tippy than an upright when doing so.

 

Hopefully production and design will not have regressed so much that we are left with machines that are not even as advanced as today's plasticrap models.. which by the way, I've determined are part of all industries' planned obsolescence to encourage future sales of most appliance types.   It is a shame, but thankfully our beloved vintage vacs will still be going strong for decades to come and we can rely on enjoying those machines!


Post# 398599 , Reply# 7   9/22/2018 at 13:45 (2,041 days old) by fan-of-fans (USA)        

fan-of-fans's profile picture
I think part of it is people don't vacuum as often or thoroughly these days. It's a hassle and they just use Swiffers on those hard floor surfaces instead of getting out a vacuum.

While older canisters boasted full attachment sets to clean floors to furniture, most people today don't clean house like that anymore. They might get out the vacuum to clean under the refrigerator or vacuum a rug, but they aren't going to use it to clean table tops, lampshades, etc. They don't even think about it that way. If they need to dust they use a rag or the Swiffer and spread the dust around instead.

Of course they will still buy one of those bagless uprights as long as it has a bare floor shut off, even if it isn't all that practical to have in a house with all hard floors.

All of the vacuum shops here closed 15+ years ago. There's no where to go to get a Miele or anything like that, I doubt anyone has anything that nice, unless it's a Kirby or maybe an Aerus. If you want a fancier canister you have to go to the appliance store and get an Oreck one or go to Sears and get a Kenmore. That's about all there is. If you go anywhere else you might see a bagless Bissell straight suction and that's all.


Post# 398606 , Reply# 8   9/22/2018 at 16:01 (2,040 days old) by dysonman1 (the county)        

dysonman1's profile picture
As someone who repairs vacuums for a living (in addition to selling them and demonstrating them), I prefer canisters that do NOT have the controls in the handle. I'm NOT a fan of PC Boards, which are required if you have controls in the handle of the hose. I love the full size attachments on the Riccar Prima. That machine was built to run for a long time.

Post# 398612 , Reply# 9   9/22/2018 at 22:28 (2,040 days old) by gottahaveahoove (Pittston, Pennsylvania, 18640)        
Our family used uprights, primarily. (Hoovers, of course)

gottahaveahoove's profile picture
However, a few are canister fans, and own mostly Constellations, Portables, and the like.
Although, my sister is a huge fan of canisters, she still has her first "Dimension". It naturally still works at peak performance. She's never experienced any kind of trouble with her appliance as she, like the rest of us, takes care of her vacuum.
She always liked the power nozzle. It saved her from hoing, scrubbing, etc, freeing her from, say, suffering from carpal tunnel. After she vacuums, she has free time to enjoy the nice weather, say, enjoying her swing, porch or yard.
Of course, she, too, is not one to bash any other makes. She's far too refined for that.


Post# 398618 , Reply# 10   9/22/2018 at 23:48 (2,040 days old) by Vacuumdevil (Vacuum Hell )        
not worldwide.

vacuumdevil's profile picture
Canister vacuums dominate the worldwide Market.
Tacony dealers should not be an example of anything the vacuum industry is doing as a whole.
You do not need a parking slot for a powerhead that stays up by itself.


target="_blank">m.youtube.com/watchQUESTIONMARKR...

I would agree with you since the 1980a USA canister sales have been in a decline.
But then you see companies like shark repackaging canisters as uprights.

I will tell you canisters bringing a lot of business to Independent retail.


Post# 398621 , Reply# 11   9/23/2018 at 00:50 (2,040 days old) by tolivac (Greenville,NC)        

Manufactured or engineered floors can contribute MORE formaldehyde into the home environment than carpet!!So you may be better off with the carpet or solid,REAL wood flooring.Lumber Liquidators is facing lawsuits on the effects of the engineered floors they sell.A bonus with hardwood or other solid wood floors-they can be refinished a few times before needing to be replaced.Synthetic,engineered floors CANNOT be refineshed and end up in the landfill.Carpet can last longer than those,too.

Post# 398624 , Reply# 12   9/23/2018 at 01:10 (2,040 days old) by completenutt (West Hollywood, California)        
Agreed, Rex! Real wood materials are better for many reasons

completenutt's profile picture

Hope you survived Florence okay.  Best wishes.


Post# 398626 , Reply# 13   9/23/2018 at 01:48 (2,040 days old) by gregvacs28 (U.S.)        
carpet vs vynil or laminate


good points about the petroleum off-gassing.
Carpet and pad is about an 1 1/2" of pure petroleum products woven or glued together. Older stuff may have had asbestos in it.

Laminate or vynil is essentially the same thickness but there is foam underlayment then compressed and glued particle board and on top that is plastic.

If it's vvynil floor there is the particle board or plywood underlayment, then glue, then pure petroleum products with a hard surface.

Even "real" 3/4" t&G oak, maple, walnut, pine, or other wood floor should be sealed. And what is it finished with? It's suggested to use several layers of a petroleum based (and stinky) sealer.

I know it's wrong but I love me some traditional 80s plush carpeting with a dense rebond pad. Also those shiny 12' wide vynil floors of the 90s in a white or off-white pattern. (No, you really can't find them much anymore)
I'm guilty.

This is another reason I love central vacuum. It sucks up the chemical off gassing and pumps the stink outside with the fine dust. People don't see the chemicals and thus don't think about that. They don't realize a vented vacuum can remove that too. A (vented) Central vacuum acts as an exhaust fan.


Post# 398632 , Reply# 14   9/23/2018 at 06:38 (2,040 days old) by tolivac (Greenville,NC)        

I and my house survived just fine-think we dodged the bullet on this one-if it hit where it was originally predicted-then I would have had a harder time.
Vinyl flooring isn't so bad since it doesn't outgas as bad as the formadehyde based coverings.The finish for wooden floors isn't considered hazardous after its dry.Keep in mind not all central vacuums are vented.Those that use HEPA style bags and filters typically are not vented since they don't have fine dust in their exhaust.Also the toxic floors emit the gas wether the vacuum cleaner is on or not.Remember a period of time long ago when asbestos tile was removed with a floor sander equipped with like 25-36 grit sanding belts-the bags on those didn't filter the asbestos.Now the tile is scraped up intact with a motorized floor scraper.A floor contractor used one here at work.Was sort of fun to use and safer for the tile removal than a floor sander-grinder.Now floor sanders have truckmounted dust bins and filters so the dust is sucked out of the house or building-a hose goes to the output of the sander.also the inside of the building is then largely dust free-so the contactor doesn't have to remove or cover furniture.The suction fan is run by a PTO from the trucks engine or a separate engine.The giant bag is disposable and taken to the landfill.


Post# 398639 , Reply# 15   9/23/2018 at 09:08 (2,040 days old) by n0oxy (Saint Louis Missouri, United States)        
floors

My apartment is all hard wood floors, not sure of the type of wood, it was replaced in 2001, if I was offered the option to have carpet installed I would say no thanks, even though I am well equiped to clean it, I have just about every power nozzle that is available and I use those to clean my area rugs outside the door. I have a variety of hard floor tools that I use with my canisters, backpacks or free standing central vacuum units. To try to clean that with an upright would be difficult at best which is why I much prefer a canister cleaner of some type. The only upright I know of that is well equiped to clean hard floors is the Sebo Felix because you can remove the power nozzle and attach a hard floor brush just like a canister. Other than that, a canister would probably clean circles around an upright on hard floors.
Hey Rex, are you enjoying your Drainvac Atomik? I used mine yesterday, it really is an awesome little machine. I would love to know how they got that strong of a motor in to a vacuum unit of that size. I think Drainvac is the only central vacuum company that uses Domel motors instead of Ametek.
Mike


Post# 398642 , Reply# 16   9/23/2018 at 11:26 (2,040 days old) by fan-of-fans (USA)        

fan-of-fans's profile picture
My house has both tile floors and carpet. I use the uprights on the carpet and the canisters on the tile or carpet if they have power nozzles. I would have to have at least a large area rug in my house so I could put my uprights to use. Otherwise I couldn't use them. I don't like using an upright on tile even if the brush is off because they don't have bristles to sweep up the dust and they seem heavier to push with the brush off.

Post# 398675 , Reply# 17   9/24/2018 at 00:33 (2,039 days old) by tolivac (Greenville,NC)        

Mike:The Drainvac is doing fine-filled up one of the bags--just threw it out!Taping the zipper prevents any chance of it opening while the vacuum is running.Will check with them if they have bags that don't have zippers.The machine works WELL with a Volt powernozzle.My most frequently used powernozzle.When you look into the exhaust port on the Dranvac you will see the Domel motor takes up most of the space inside the machine!Just that-like a jet fighter plane-the engine takes up most of the fuselage .

Post# 398678 , Reply# 18   9/24/2018 at 04:35 (2,039 days old) by electromatik (Taylorsville, North Carolina, U.S.A.)        

Good convo… It looks like manufacturers focus mostly on uprights these days. Canisters are seemingly withering on the vine.

It seems like we've now reached a time when the dominance of uprights is just about total.


Post# 398689 , Reply# 19   9/24/2018 at 09:15 (2,039 days old) by gottahaveahoove (Pittston, Pennsylvania, 18640)        
I recently refinished all of the real hardwood

gottahaveahoove's profile picture
floors in my house. they were installed in 1942 ! The house was built circa 1876 !
The 2 bathrooms are ceramic tile, and, only my room and the staircase/hall are carpeted, (Karastan). The other rugs in the house are Chinese wool.The Hoover gallery, (cats' apartment), is soon to be renovated. I'm still debating on real wood or carpeting in there.
I'm not a fan of Pergo type flooring, for various reasons.
I like real textiles.
It's true: we're seeing more and more vacs being 'uprights' that convert to 'canisters'.....appealing to both, I guess.
Again, being the purist that I am, (also called a snob, among other things), lolo I like real canisters and real uprights. I have both. Personally not a fan of the 'combo flooring OR vacs'.


Post# 398700 , Reply# 20   9/24/2018 at 14:41 (2,038 days old) by GREGVACS28 (U.S.)        
John


How does one determine what a "real" textile is?

12x12 peel and stick floor tile are real?
berber or wool carpet is real, isn't it?
70s thick shag carpet in Skateworld Orange is real, right?
ceramic floors?


Post# 398703 , Reply# 21   9/24/2018 at 15:18 (2,038 days old) by gottahaveahoove (Pittston, Pennsylvania, 18640)        
What I mean is.......

gottahaveahoove's profile picture
real hardwood flooring, being made of oak, as compared to laminate, simulated woodgrain over vinyl. Ceramic tile, having been fired in a kiln with a glaze, etc. Don't get me wrong, some vinyl products are great.(I'm not bashing).
I, (personally) don't like the sound of shoes going over a padded composite with a wood design on it. I've seen them peel at the ends. I'd rather spend money once than have to 'redo'.
I gutted both bathrooms here. They are now all ceramic tile. Yes, they have both advantages as well as disadvantages. Hardwood floors are finished now with finishes which need very little care/upkeep. 25 years ago, I put white (I KNOW) Karastan wall to wall in my room. There is NO wear to it at all. If it were now, I'd do it differently. But, a good Convertible and an occasional Hoover steamer, and it's like brand new once again.


Post# 398704 , Reply# 22   9/24/2018 at 15:22 (2,038 days old) by gottahaveahoove (Pittston, Pennsylvania, 18640)        
Should I have said,

gottahaveahoove's profile picture
'natural' textile? Yes, a peel and stick floor tile IS real.... unless your name is Cybil, perhaps. Then, we might not be so sure.
Real plastic, real vinyl, real composite, (real, simulated, imitation vinyl woodgrain), etc.
I would say saccharin might not be real, but, that's not a textile.


Post# 398705 , Reply# 23   9/24/2018 at 16:04 (2,038 days old) by bryan1980 (Texas)        

Our Epic 6500 is the most-used vacuum in my collection. We have hard floors throughout the living area, and an area rug in the living room. One big advantage it has over an upright is the ability to get into tight spaces and under furniture. The only thing I don't like about it is how small the bags are, but at least they're cheap!

Still use the Kirby for the carpeted areas.


Post# 398709 , Reply# 24   9/24/2018 at 19:04 (2,038 days old) by KirbyClassicIII (Milwaukie, Oregon)        

kirbyclassiciii's profile picture
I see your points about the present state of the canister vacuum market, but these days there also aren't a whole lot of replacement parts still being made for the canister cleaners we do still have and those we like a lot.

~Ben


Post# 398712 , Reply# 25   9/24/2018 at 21:37 (2,038 days old) by Rivstg1 (colorado springs)        
I’m more of a upright guy but...

rivstg1's profile picture
I do enjoy my canister Rainbow, and am considering a Filter Queen Majestic recently( reading up on them now), but, maybe I’m simple ....I enjoy converting my Kirby to canister mode....seems to work just as well....everything clean in its wake! I am amazed at canisters are becoming more and more rare though

Post# 398727 , Reply# 26   9/25/2018 at 00:52 (2,038 days old) by GREGVACS28 (U.S.)        
Reminds me of when I discovered



Goodwill, back in about 1980. Why Goodwill? Because back then Goodwill was "Pure". If stuff came in as a donation, It got put on the floor, just about Anything. It wasn't cleaned, the cord was not wrapped, the shelves were not matching, the store was not professionally decorated, etc.

Goodwill back then looked like a Mom and Pop type thrift store of today: Donated shelves, rough edges, no perfumes to "neutralize" odors, and only donated bags at checkout. Certainly no credit cards accepted. It was beautiful.

The good thing about this is you were sure to find something when ever you went. They had building materials, major appliances, live plants, a book section, a record section, a musical instrument section, and more. And the small appliance section was sure to be teaming with vacuums. And they often were just thrown on the shelf, they might even be sitting on the floor. And that floor was not clean.

To start, I found a 1977ish yellow Hoover Celebrity with electric hose and no PN. A green 1974 Kenmore canister with electric hose. 1968 Kenmore PN with no bottom plate, a 1977 coffee color Kenmore portable washer with hoses dangling off the back, a 1976 Kenmore middle range washer, I bought new hollow core doors, a bedside brass lamp with wood spindle with the price written on it in crayon (1.77). lol
If I went to Goodwill now and things looked and smelled like this, I think I would pee my pants on the spot(which would contribute to the smell). It looked kind of like a Habitat for humanity store, but with a bunch of clothing racks in the middle.
There were no plastic Bissells back then.


Post# 398741 , Reply# 27   9/25/2018 at 04:41 (2,038 days old) by GREGVACS28 (U.S.)        
"real" stuff



John, the reason I talk about this is not to put you on the spot but because one hears about "real" products vs some supposed inferior product, often.

In the 90s for example, where I used to live, I used to be involved in new home construction and some subdivisions would have covenants stating that all new homes had to have "natural exteriors" and "NO man-made products" . This is laughable. They would actually use those terms. They were trying to dictate to people to use cedar or stone and trying to keep people from using aluminum or vinyl products. Right like that that's going to hold up in a court of law.

It's like, remind me what tree or plant cedar siding grows on, or where are bricks dug out of the ground, or what plant cut field stone comes from.
They are all "man-made" products. And cedar siding that's been coated with primer and than painted has gone through the same process that aluminum siding has gone through.

If you go back to some of these McMansion subdivisions, 15 to 25 years on, some of these homes look really crappy and the property values often have not increased. According to Zillow and other sites, values have sometimes decreased. People that don't know, or can't afford to often paint or stain or retuck mortar end up with decay that one wouldn't have on an aluminum sided house.

I like what I like and am not concerned about publicized attitudes that are often ignorant, biased, and baseless.

I would happily take your " white .... Karastan wall to wall (carpeting)."
You clearly have good taste. And you're correct, choosing products that are going to hold up can save a lot of hassle and money in the long run.


Post# 398754 , Reply# 28   9/25/2018 at 13:04 (2,038 days old) by gottahaveahoove (Pittston, Pennsylvania, 18640)        
Greg, I was not upset at all.

gottahaveahoove's profile picture
I agree with you totally. I know all about those McMansions too. It's a shame.
I, personally like to buy, use, etc the 'real stuff' over the other stuff, when I can.
The "Hoover gallery/cats' apartment is the next 'project'. Being that there will be various vacuums, carpeting might be the way to go. That white Karastan in my room looks like it snowed in there. It also shows PERFECT Hoover tracks!
When I had it installed 25 yrs ago, my late mother said, "That's gonna get dirty". I WISH !!
Thanks for the compliments.
John


Post# 398911 , Reply# 29   9/29/2018 at 00:15 (2,034 days old) by myles_v (Fredericksburg, VA)        

myles_v's profile picture
I'm a huge fan of canisters, I prefer them to uprights for day-to-day cleaning. It's a shame that they're not offered in big box stores, but there isn't much offered in big box stores that's worth buying anyways so it wouldn't mean much if they came back to stores like Walmart.

Miele is definitely still focused on canisters, their main markets primarily use canisters. The US isn't Miele's main market, they definitely have more brand recognition in Europe. European countries tend to favor canisters. Miele's tools are a joke, unfortunately, but their upright tools aren't any better than the tools offered for their canisters.


Post# 398914 , Reply# 30   9/29/2018 at 00:30 (2,034 days old) by fan-of-fans (USA)        

fan-of-fans's profile picture
I saw Lowes sells one Bissell, bagless straight suction. Walmart sells Eureka bagless canisters, one with a PN (may be discontinued now that Eureka was sold).

Kmart had more canisters than most stores, but they closed.

I prefer canisters too, but I think most people these days don't have a clue how to use attachments on a vacuum. To them it's just a machine to clean the floor, so an upright makes more sense.


Post# 398925 , Reply# 31   9/29/2018 at 08:49 (2,034 days old) by n0oxy (Saint Louis Missouri, United States)        
attachments

In many cases, the attachments that are actually included with a canister cleaner are not the best. Fortunately most canister hose ends are standard size and can use other attachments and there are many to choose from. The best attachments are probably the ones that are included with central vacuum kits but they can be purchased separately. My favorite attachments are the ones for cleaning hard floors and I have several of those.
Mike



Forum Index:       Other Forums:                      



Comes to the Rescue!

Woops, Time to Check the Bag!!!
Either you need to change your vacuum bag or you forgot to LOG-IN?

Discuss-O-MAT Log-In



New Members
Click Here To Sign Up.



                     


automaticwasher.org home
Discuss-o-Mat Forums
Vintage Brochures, Service and Owners Manuals
Fun Vintage Washer Ephemera
See It Wash!
Video Downloads
Audio Downloads
Picture of the Day
Patent of the Day
Photos of our Collections
The Old Aberdeen Farm
Vintage Service Manuals
Vintage washer/dryer/dishwasher to sell?
Technical/service questions?
Looking for Parts?
Website related questions?
Digital Millennium Copyright Act Policy
Our Privacy Policy