Thread Number: 20465
Cleaning Comparison Old vs. New
[Down to Last]

Vacuumland's exclusive eBay Watch:
scroll >>> for more items --- [As an eBay Partner, eBay may compensate vacuumland.org if you make a purchase using any link to eBay on this page]
Post# 229137   4/19/2013 at 19:11 (4,018 days old) by Codyhoover ()        

After restoring my Hoover 541, I got curious as to how it cleaned compared to a modern Dyson DC 25. So, I did a test between the two. Before the test, I made sure the Hoover's bag was thoroughly beaten out and the Dyson's bin was emptied. I divided a rug equally in half and vacuumed one side of the rug twice with each vacuum. A picture of the results is below. It appears that the Dyson sucked up more pet hair while the Hoover sucked up more fine dust and dirt.

Post# 229139 , Reply# 1   4/19/2013 at 19:12 (4,018 days old) by Codyhoover ()        

My test setup:

Post# 229186 , Reply# 2   4/20/2013 at 06:32 (4,017 days old) by kenkart ()        
And WHAT damages rugs most!

That fine dirt the ancient Hoover got out! When you really consider everything, how long it has lasted, quietness,performance,there really is no comparison, the Hoover wins hands down, now if you really want to embarrass the Dyson, get a model 61,62 or 63 Hoover, or a Eureka 260...its ALL over then!

Post# 229192 , Reply# 3   4/20/2013 at 07:31 (4,017 days old) by 1926700 ()        
or a......

Eureka with a Rugulator, and a Vibra-Groomer I (one). Possibly also a Higher end Eureka Power team canister, Like a Empress II, or TOL Roto-Matic

Post# 229196 , Reply# 4   4/20/2013 at 08:34 (4,017 days old) by williamr1248 (USA)        
Cleaning Comparison old vs new

Hans,
I could not agree with you more. I had a vac meet this last week and was showing some where the Dysons and new Hoovers had caused damage to several of my area rugs.
I could use an old Electrolux or Hoover till the cows come home and not see any visable damage to the same rugs. I think this is why some of the consumer testing results will rate cleaners as picking up the most dirt,the fastest but at what cost of damage to the rugs? My Windtunnel bag would be filled with dog hair and fuzz from the carpet but EVERY time the Rainbow basin or the bottom of the old Hoover bag will have much finer sand and grit and very little rug fiber in comparison.
Of course to be fair,in today's world most people move,replace or change their rugs out long before they ever wear out. Carpets are not such a huge investment as they were years ago.
It all depends on what type of results you value. I lot of consumers want instant results.


Post# 229237 , Reply# 5   4/20/2013 at 10:39 (4,017 days old) by NYCWriter (New York City)        
Well ...

nycwriter's profile picture
... rugs are not the "investment" they used to be because of plastics.

Prior to WWII, a rug was wool, and often hand-loomed or hand-woven. Room-sized rugs were really the domain of the rich; very few households of average means could afford them (this is why so many modest homes had those country-look "braided" rugs or "rag" rugs). The only other floor surfaces were hardwood or linoleum (or even leather).

Today, however, with cheap nylons and other petroleum-based polymers, carpeting is now pretty much the norm. CHEAP carpeting. All chemicals. Which is why many people need to "air out" the house for a few days before actually living with their new synthetic carpeting, because of the fumes. And while the majority of the chemicals are offgassed in those initial days, those carpets are offgassing toxic fumes over their entire lifetimes. Very unhealthy.

Wool, however, is a "living" fiber -- organic -- constantly capturing airborne pollutants and holding them (until, of course, you vaccum or wash the fibers). One of the best air purifiers in a room, believe it or not, is a large wool rug.

But ... they're expensive. My white textured wool "room-sized" rug in the bedroom (11x14) was priced at $11,000 six years ago. So there are many of us who still see our rugs as investments.


Post# 229262 , Reply# 6   4/20/2013 at 13:39 (4,017 days old) by kenkart ()        
11,000.00 !!!

Id be afraid to walk on that!!LOL, But I bet its beautiful!

Post# 229283 , Reply# 7   4/20/2013 at 14:57 (4,017 days old) by NYCWriter (New York City)        
Hans ...

nycwriter's profile picture
Well, I got a great deal on it, since I was also buying a rug for the living room.

And that's why it's white ... and in the BEDROOM ... no cross-trafic!

But SOFT! OMG. It's like walking on a cashmere sweater! And it's textured to look like river rock.

BTW ... no "outside" shoes in my apartment! Only "inside" shoes that have never crossed the threshold!


Post# 229288 , Reply# 8   4/20/2013 at 15:16 (4,017 days old) by d-jones (Pittsburgh)        

Another advantage of wool carpet is that it's naturally very fire resistant, so it's almost always the carpet of choice for corporate aircraft interiors. Other material can be used, but it has to be treated with fire retarding chemicals to pass muster. And since repeated carpet cleaning will strip those chemicals out, they have to be periodically reapplied which adds to the overall cost. But the most important feature of wool carpet, and wool fiber in general, is that when it does burn in a closed environment like a room or an aircraft interior, it doesn't produce a cloud of highly toxic gases that will kill you long before the fire does. Carpet made from various forms of plastic can be very deadly in that regard. Something to think about when choosing a carpet for your home, or your corporate jet.Wink


Post# 229290 , Reply# 9   4/20/2013 at 15:23 (4,017 days old) by NYCWriter (New York City)        
Something else to consider ...

nycwriter's profile picture
... despite what has been always said over the years, wool carpet is much easier to clean and less likely to stain than synthetic fibers.

Post# 229291 , Reply# 10   4/20/2013 at 15:27 (4,017 days old) by Paul (USA)        

Very interesting information from everyone so far--thanks for posting.  Regarding reply #5 in which various flooring types are mentioned cork should be included.  I don't know about its popularity, but it was...and is still installed.

 

Paul



Forum Index:       Other Forums:                      



Comes to the Rescue!

Woops, Time to Check the Bag!!!
Either you need to change your vacuum bag or you forgot to LOG-IN?

Discuss-O-MAT Log-In



New Members
Click Here To Sign Up.



                     


automaticwasher.org home
Discuss-o-Mat Forums
Vintage Brochures, Service and Owners Manuals
Fun Vintage Washer Ephemera
See It Wash!
Video Downloads
Audio Downloads
Picture of the Day
Patent of the Day
Photos of our Collections
The Old Aberdeen Farm
Vintage Service Manuals
Vintage washer/dryer/dishwasher to sell?
Technical/service questions?
Looking for Parts?
Website related questions?
Digital Millennium Copyright Act Policy
Our Privacy Policy