Thread Number: 21775
Motor Design
[Down to Last]

Vacuumland's exclusive eBay Watch:
scroll >>> for more items --- [As an eBay Partner, eBay may compensate vacuumland.org if you make a purchase using any link to eBay on this page]
Post# 243546   8/3/2013 at 14:27 (3,911 days old) by dressur ()        

I want to have opinions. I would love to hear from the veterans in the vac business as well. I am looking at an old Electrolux motor. I would love to design a motor that resembles it I would love to have it cast in copper for heat transfer. Would it work When I signed up on here there was a question about what modern vacuum would I love to have and to be totally honest there isn't anything made today that really rocks my world. But I have a design of motor and canister that would be a wonderful machine. I don't like cord winders and I like simple. Like my Electrolux on sleds it has a cloth bag and a hose connector on the front. no wheels to go bad no fancy manometers cord winders. ever have a vacuum you must feed the cord back into? the Dysons are ok,, but single fan high speed motors. I read about Peder Andersen Fisker who started Nilfisk even they now went from the two stage low speed low wattage motor to the 1400 watt single fan motor, and to my dismay so did Miele. SO the more I type this, I realize that this is a two fold question. One would any vac company be interested in a new motor design and two, what is the future of vacuums. is there any hope that the old two stage idea will be back or will it ever go away completely? Thanks so much Mich

Post# 243548 , Reply# 1   8/3/2013 at 14:41 (3,911 days old) by dysonman1 (the county)        

dysonman1's profile picture
2 stage, double ball bearing motors are still being made. Even for uprights (Simplicity 7850/Riccar 8955). The best vacuum motor (from the perspective of durability) today is the Rainbow brushless "Hurricane" motor. Carbon brush motors wear out proportionate to the cube of their speed. Double a motor's speed, and it wears out 8 times as fast (2 x 2 x 2 = 8). With modern vac motors, it's true that the high speed, single fan motors wear out faster - however, if you turn down the motor's speed (like you can with a Miele for example), you can achieve excellent cleaning and allow the motor to last a lot longer.

Post# 243552 , Reply# 2   8/3/2013 at 15:04 (3,911 days old) by dressur ()        

Cool. Yes I agree with the slower speed speaking of Rainbow I have my grandmother's that she bought in the 60s I guess. it is chrome and copperish colored . Never had a problem with it so far. I only use it for spills now and then but the motor is original. I think it is anyway. It is weird you can actually see the windings from the bottom. weird as heck I always wonder how water don't get sucked up into an open motored vacuum I know it's possible as I see work every time I use that Rainbow but still,,,,,mind boggling. Funny you mentioned Riccar ,when I was traveling through MO to Texas we visited that factory and they had a museum and this guy I forget his name but holy moly that guy knew more about vacuum cleaners than I though was possible to know about vacuum cleaners. That was one of the most enjoyable tourist type visits we ever had. I know a lot about motors in the scientific aspect. but I never looked under the hoods of the newer stuff and I am reading about them for fun (how I came across this website) and I am not a collector like some people are, but I look at vacuums as a power tool, anything with motors is interesting to me. and I would love to be another Peder Andersen fisker build the most high quality vacuum (and motorcycle ) that can be built. I would love to see metal come back again. Anyway I hope that the two fan motors never go away. thanks again Mich.

Post# 243553 , Reply# 3   8/3/2013 at 15:14 (3,911 days old) by dressur ()        

Here is the motor I really like. I would love to have this built in cast copper. I think this motor spins at 10,000 RPM. I like the new rainbows. Maybe I will try to get one used somewhere. I have a lot of vacuums but nothing really noteworthy not like that museum in Missouri I still can't get over that collection. Riccar must be proud to own something like that. Everyone needs to go and see that. that needs to be on the show with Larry the cable Guy. Whatever that show is called.

Post# 243555 , Reply# 4   8/3/2013 at 15:39 (3,911 days old) by vegassucks ()        
Riccar/Simplicity

I was considering a Riccar/simplicity but the reviews for deep cleaning were poor. Surprised because they are built like tanks.

Post# 243558 , Reply# 5   8/3/2013 at 15:45 (3,911 days old) by dysonman1 (the county)        
Hey Mich

dysonman1's profile picture
Here's a pic of the double stage, double ball bearing, repairable motor used in the Simplicity and Riccar vacuums. I heard about the Museum. From what I understand, the guy that works there is really a nice man, and some people would even say 'handsome'. He's really an expert when it comes to vacuums. Tacony is lucky to have him, he's irreplaceable.

Post# 243560 , Reply# 6   8/3/2013 at 15:54 (3,911 days old) by dressur ()        

yes!! That is a neat looking motor. do they use them in their canisters too? Yes and that guy didn't mind taking all the time and questions just enjoyed talking about vacuums. What's more they are building vacuums in USA not China. that was what I read. I need to go to Vegas when I do I am going through that museum again.

Post# 243561 , Reply# 7   8/3/2013 at 16:00 (3,911 days old) by vegassucks ()        
Nice motors, poor brush roller

www.goodhousekeeping.com/product-...

See the above link. $1,500 upright with poor deep cleaning? I have seen the motor used and it is massive so the problem must be the brush roller, while powerful it is not chevron patterned and can be the only reason a machine so powerful would not deep clean.


Post# 243563 , Reply# 8   8/3/2013 at 16:23 (3,911 days old) by dressur ()        

I never owned a Simplicity or Riccar. I liked the machines that were there that were for sale. I couldn't afford them as the cost of diesel for the motorhome kinda took most of our "fun" money away. That motor looks impressive. I hope they put that motor in the canisters that would be a neat vacuum for sure. I have 10 or so vacuums and most are Nilfisks that were used at a company for their building and I bought them all. I have one three motor job I use in my garage and I have one in the motorhome and one on each floor the rest are parts machines if I ever need them. I got that old Electrolux and Grandma's old rainbow. but I want to learn more about vacuum motor design. I don't like the single fan motors.

Post# 243564 , Reply# 9   8/3/2013 at 16:30 (3,911 days old) by dysonman1 (the county)        

dysonman1's profile picture
It's complete Bull that the Riccar/Simplicity vacuums don't deep clean well. The steel brush roller and two suction motors make a vacuum that will outclean almost any other vacuum on the market. Here's a pic of the brush roller.

Post# 243567 , Reply# 10   8/3/2013 at 16:42 (3,911 days old) by vegassucks ()        
Deep cleaning Riccar

Many bad reviews from owners also of the Riccar also. I have never owned one and the Riccar seems well built, I have read other places that the suction was not very good. Some of the others vacuums on the Good Housekeeping reviews that I am familiar with we're spot on.

Post# 243582 , Reply# 11   8/3/2013 at 18:48 (3,911 days old) by dressur ()        

I don't know. when I visited the Museum in St Louis or wherever it was. it was outside of St Louis west on I44. They had the museum and they had in there their vacuums and they let you use them and give them a spin. I don't know they seem to be of quality and looking at that motor I would have to agree that it is Bull, that they have bad things said. I don't pay attention to consumer reports or good housekeeping as they don't talk about what makes things work they don't get into the motors of the vacuums, they I think are biased. I am not into the look of those machines as I like simple metal units. But that is me and my personal interests and attitudes that have NO bearing on what is good what is bad, just what I myself like and don't like. I like simple roundish canisters. My nilfisks which are mostly metal except one which is grey plastic I do like. it is simple in that it has no cord winder to go bad and speed controls or circuit boards. I do know about the Rainbow motor being a Switched Reluctance motor, which means that a circuit board switches on and off sequentially coils and the laminate rotor that is segmented follows the sequence. they have been around for many years. I like that idea but the computer board. Now if I was in the market for a modern vacuum like Miele or the new Nilfisks like the power or king or any vacuum I would go with the simplicity canister as I had a real nice experience with that company. nicest people I ever met. Also I think that any bad reference to their products could be sour grapes from a troll that might have been fired or whathaveyou
Back to motors. I want to design one like the Nilfisk motor I posted, but make it out of cast copper as copper is one of the best heat transfer mediums and relatively cheap and long lasting and I would love to design a vacuum cleaner made out of brass. I only have two no three simple issues to get over then I can get it done, one, money, Two, would there be buyers for my design Three, What company would build my design. Simple right? I know I will never get it done but I would love to have it made.


Post# 243583 , Reply# 12   8/3/2013 at 19:17 (3,911 days old) by dressur ()        

I just looked at your profile (Dysonman) and are you with the Company? I think the guy was named Tim. maybe it was Tom. I am terrible with names. Anyway if this is you!!! I was blown away with what you knew about a vacuum cleaner. This color means that this vacuum was made in 1950 something now if it has this color something it was made in 1954 How do you know all of this???? It is mind boggling, That is if this is you. The museum and factory was in St James. that is right.

Post# 243588 , Reply# 13   8/3/2013 at 19:51 (3,911 days old) by dressur ()        

one last thing, what is the motor in an Electrolux with the sleds on the bottom made out of? cast aluminum or zinc? anyone know?? thanks.

Post# 243598 , Reply# 14   8/3/2013 at 22:35 (3,911 days old) by vegassucks ()        
Riccar/simplicity The Truth

The truth about Riccar/simplicity is they are assembled in the United States but their parts are mainly from Korea and elsewhere. Read you labels more carefully. Their higher end units have issues with dirty motor blades breaking which could cause you to lose a motor and they do not hold up even as well as a top line Panasonic. Their clean air units are much better units but at the price they sell them you can purchase a better Panasonic.

The Riccar/Simplicity is nowhere near the quality of Sebo, Miele, Lindhaus or high end Panasonics.


Post# 243599 , Reply# 15   8/3/2013 at 22:47 (3,911 days old) by dressur ()        

Yeah I don't know,, I just like the welcoming attitude they had, the Museum Curator that I talked too was so interested in talking to me and talked about the vacuums and they let you tour the factory. I would like to have the Nilfisk UZ930 I wonder how they fare to the ones you mentioned. I also would love to know if a company would welcome my designs. that would be awesome! I wonder if Riccar would. Or someone.

Post# 243602 , Reply# 16   8/3/2013 at 23:37 (3,911 days old) by kenkart ()        
Re Motor design..

The first really high performance canister motor was a single fan design, Apex made it for their Strato Cleaner,it was great...but, it drew about 11 to 12 amps, not a problem today, but in 1953 when it came out, many houses were not wired for a appliance that drew that much power, also, if the bags were not changed often enough, it had a tendency to run hot, thus shortening its life, but as for sheer power, nothing on the market even came close from 1953 until 1958 when Sunbeam introduced the Dual Deluxe, which also was a single fan machine, and was very much the equal of the Apex.

Post# 243603 , Reply# 17   8/3/2013 at 23:39 (3,911 days old) by kenkart ()        
And the motor

It was an"Upside down " motor, the air passed over the armature before entering the fan chamber, like a GE or AirWay motor.My hand shows how big the fan is!

Post# 243604 , Reply# 18   8/3/2013 at 23:40 (3,911 days old) by kenkart ()        
Top

View.

Post# 243605 , Reply# 19   8/3/2013 at 23:46 (3,911 days old) by dressur ()        

Here is my favorite vacuum I own. This is what I call serious motor power.

Post# 243606 , Reply# 20   8/3/2013 at 23:49 (3,911 days old) by dressur ()        

WOW!!!V that Apex is COOL!!! see these are my favorite style canisters

Post# 243608 , Reply# 21   8/3/2013 at 23:52 (3,911 days old) by dressur ()        

I want one of these

Post# 243617 , Reply# 22   8/4/2013 at 00:01 (3,911 days old) by dressur ()        

Do you like the upside down motor design?? I don't have a GE vacuum motor don't know what they look like,, are they good too?

Post# 243622 , Reply# 23   8/4/2013 at 00:36 (3,911 days old) by dressur ()        

I have insomnia tonight and took a picture of two Nilfisk motors I cleaned up, when I got my Nilfisks they were dirty and some had paint on them and stuff. you can imagine the filters on top were dirty. I looked at the prices of those filters that go under the grill and they are like 10 bucks.. I make my own. At Wally world I went (with my Girlfriend she loves crafts anyway) and I asked her to get me some felt, 23 cents for 14 by 14 inch. cut out the filters and they work like the originals and I stack two, one on top of each other and it has more airflow and suction. I like the way the red looks,, kinda cool. I wish I had a silver Nilfisk only the gray metal ones and the plastic job, which I like a lot. lightweight.

Post# 243677 , Reply# 24   8/4/2013 at 16:46 (3,910 days old) by kenkart ()        
I Have a

GS-80 and a GS-90, they are great vacuums, Hard to find parts though.

Post# 243696 , Reply# 25   8/4/2013 at 17:25 (3,910 days old) by dressur ()        

yeah I guess cause they are foreign?? I hope they don't need parts.

Post# 243726 , Reply# 26   8/4/2013 at 20:42 (3,910 days old) by kenkart ()        
No, both of mine run great,

Bags have to be ordered and are expensive and because the wands are an odd size, no attachments can be used but Nilfisk, I currently need an upholstery tool and crevice tool.

Post# 243736 , Reply# 27   8/4/2013 at 21:53 (3,910 days old) by dressur ()        

yeah I have a wand that was crushed and a hose a big green one for that three motor job is crushed in the middle. I have to figure something out. I like canisters that are simple no cord winder. I am thinking of buying a new sanitaire round type canister looks somewhat like an advance u930 like a big cake box deal. this is red and black,,

Post# 243737 , Reply# 28   8/4/2013 at 22:04 (3,910 days old) by dressur ()        

what about this vacuum setup. it is a Sebo and according to the pictorial aid goes through motor than fans,,, does anyone have a picture of the motor of this unit? thanks I want to learn all the different motors.

Post# 243759 , Reply# 29   8/5/2013 at 05:32 (3,909 days old) by tolivac (Greenville,NC)        

Bags for a Nilfisk-I have a Nilfisk GS80 I got from the trade in pile from the Kirby guy.It is a GREAT vacuum-gets as much use as my Meiles,Sebo D4.I can adapt Sebo Filtrete D4 bags for the Nilfisk-just use the sanding drum in a Dremel tool to slightly enlarge the Sebo bag-it then fits onto the bag feed horn in the Nilfisk.I am using the Nilfisk for awhile-do like it.But--How do you remove the hose from the canister?I can't get how the hose comes off.Like its LONG detacheable cord-only have to plug it once-like the NSS M1 or the Sebo D4.The Nilfisk I have doesn't have an outlet for a powernozzle or electrified hose.Has a turbine type carpet tool.

Post# 243964 , Reply# 30   8/5/2013 at 20:19 (3,909 days old) by dressur ()        

You need to get a Nilfisk electrified hose form Nilfisk it has that EIC that plugs into the vacuum as the cord but after you plug in the cord from the hose then you plug in the cord. The Nilfisk power nozzle has a power switch that is foot operated on the nozzle.

Post# 243965 , Reply# 31   8/5/2013 at 20:37 (3,909 days old) by dressur ()        

oh the hose,, you just turn it counter clockwise and it will come out. It has four tits that lock into the receptacle. Once removed you'll see those four tits and the cut out of them in the vacuum. Clock wise to tighten it. give it a good twist it is in there fairly tight.

Post# 244012 , Reply# 32   8/6/2013 at 03:39 (3,909 days old) by tolivac (Greenville,NC)        

Thanks Mike-will try to see if the hose comes out tomorrow.When i have tried-its kinda tight-think it hasn't been removed for awhile by the previous user.Just wanted to verify that the hose would detach from the machine.The powernozzle hose and nozzle sounds interesting-will have to check on that-there are no Nilfisk dealers in Greenville-the machine came from the Kirby dealer in Raleigh.Guess there is a Nilfisk dealer there.

Post# 244023 , Reply# 33   8/6/2013 at 05:51 (3,908 days old) by kenkart ()        
RE Nilfisk

I guarantee there is no dust coming out of that thing!! One of the best filtering machines made.

Post# 244027 , Reply# 34   8/6/2013 at 06:05 (3,908 days old) by tolivac (Greenville,NC)        

There is comprehensive filtration in the Nilfisk-has the top mounted HEPA filter-and its pretty clean.How funny it was traded in for a Kirby-the Nilfisk would beat the Kirby in filtering-but the Kirby would beat the turbine powernozzle for performance.

Post# 244028 , Reply# 35   8/6/2013 at 06:18 (3,908 days old) by dressur ()        

I have an electrified hose and powernozzle for one of my Nilfisks, (the plastic one) and it really cleans and I have a Burmese cat and a dog, my carpet is clean.

Post# 244051 , Reply# 36   8/6/2013 at 10:09 (3,908 days old) by dysonman1 (the county)        

dysonman1's profile picture
Love my 1960's Nilfisk. Very quiet.

Post# 244152 , Reply# 37   8/6/2013 at 19:03 (3,908 days old) by dressur ()        

That's the one I would love to find... Mine are grey metal and one plastic. That is a beautiful machine.

Post# 244203 , Reply# 38   8/7/2013 at 04:36 (3,908 days old) by tolivac (Greenville,NC)        

The Nilfisk "Silver Bullet" GS80 is very similar to Dysonman1's picture-mine has the HEPA filter on top.Mike-I tried what you said on the hose-this time it came right off and could be put back on wihout difficulty-guess I just didn't have the right "knack" that day.The hose cuff end on mine has a clever swivel that allows the cuff to swivel into various positions.Pretty neat.I use my Kirby Sentria for my WW carpet-but use my "new" Nilfisk,or the Sebo D4,NSS M1 or a Meile S8 for the canister jobs-the Kirby hose and tools are pretty lonely.Use them on occasion-just for the heck of it.I do really like the long cord on the Nilfisk and the long hose-you can reach areas that other machines can't reach without lifting the machine up.And the Nilfisk can use regular 1.25" vacuum tools.The Kirby dust brush works well on it.How funny--the Kirby tools get used on other vacs at my place besides the Kirby.

Post# 244206 , Reply# 39   8/7/2013 at 06:30 (3,907 days old) by dressur ()        

Yes my electrified hose has that swivel. I only have two Nilfisk cords for all the ones I have. I use a Kirby legend red colored cord as one of my Nilfisk cords is craking and can see wire through the insulation. I also use a computer cord and then an extension cord. I like mine. I have a two motor unit that is oval in shape. That has the HEPA filters on top. but the rest are HEPAless. I have a few single motor oval shaped units too. I would love to have a silver unit. I hope to find one. I love that one Dysonman1 has.. beautiful machine Looks like it has the same motor as my three motor unit.

Post# 244403 , Reply# 40   8/8/2013 at 03:56 (3,907 days old) by tolivac (Greenville,NC)        

Noticed in the picture of Dysonman1's Nilfisk it has the swivel on both sides of the hose-the tool end and the end that attaches to the vacuum.And his has a woven hose-very nice-the woven hoses look so nice but can be stiff as boards to use-guess for old ones.It appears the Nilfisk uses a DIN type cord beside from Nilfisk would think that those cords can be gotten about anywhere-yes even from computers-since those use DIN type plugs on the computer power inlet.That seems to be a standard for computers and related data gear.There is a DIN type connector -pigtail on one of my NSS M1 vacs-so you could use the NSS powernozzle with it.Guess the Nilfisk powernozzle may fit on the M1 with the 1.5-1.25 adaptor-which I have several of.Will ask the Kirby guy next time I see him if a powernozzle did come with the Nilfisk.Would be neat!Sometimes you don't know what is in his trade in piles!

Post# 244444 , Reply# 41   8/8/2013 at 12:27 (3,906 days old) by dressur ()        

Yes the power nozzle looks a lot like a power nozzle my friend's Kenmore has. it is one of those bagless ones. My Nilfisk power nozzle has a step on and off power switch on the top of it. Maybe drill a 3/8 hole and go to mouser or online place and get a push on push off switch install it in a power nozzle. That is what I am going to do to get another power nozzle as my Nilfisk one is in shambles. I can get a used sebo nozzle at a local vac shop for 50 bucks, and I would like to put that on my Nilfisk.

Post# 244446 , Reply# 42   8/8/2013 at 12:44 (3,906 days old) by dressur ()        

I love my plastic Nilfisk hoses. I don't like the green hoses that came with my big nilfisks, they are unruly and a pain in the a$$ to use. I remember my Mother had an Electrolux in the 70s and it had the cloth hose and seemed to be stiff as my green Nilfisk hoses. I hate those green hoses.

Post# 244447 , Reply# 43   8/8/2013 at 12:52 (3,906 days old) by dressur ()        

One more thing regarding cords. I use a red Kirby cord. It has the IEC or DIN end like a computer, has a slit cut into it where a ground would be, it fits into my motor. I don't know what a new Nilfisk cord would cost,, and don't want to know :>)

Post# 244509 , Reply# 44   8/8/2013 at 15:27 (3,906 days old) by ralph123 (Little Rock, AR)        
CR's opinion

Regarding the cleaning performance of the Riccar Radiance, Consumer Reports gave it "Excellent" scores for (1) cleaning carpet, (2) cleaning bare floors, and (3) cleaning dog hair.

I'm not sold on the idea of the tandem fans on the Radiance. I own a Simplicity 7 Series and it's an excellent vacuum.


Post# 244606 , Reply# 45   8/9/2013 at 02:14 (3,906 days old) by tolivac (Greenville,NC)        

My Nilfisk has the grey plastic hose-works well-easy to use.My Tornado Wet-Dry vacuum has a HORRIBLE clear plastic hose that is stiff,and brittle.Will have to replace it with a 1.5" hose from the vac place here-Mike can do that if you supply him with the old hose connectors.
I have 3 Riccar Tamdem air vacuums and I am not boweled over by their performance-Feel my Kirbys and metal Royals are better.Now if Riccar would SIMPLIFY the airpath on those tandem air machines-bet the performance would greatly improve.And less clogging.One of mine clogged-and it was a NIGHTMARE to take down the machine and remove the clog-peice of a toothpick-a Kirby or Royal metal would eat that with no problems.And sometimes-like the Royal Powercast the Riccar machine will trip the breaker.I think if Riccar ditches the on board hose and tools,simplify the airpath-the machine would perform better and be lighter.Would like to see a separate hose-like the Kirby or Royal-and make it use BOTH motors.The former dealer did show how tough these can be-a customer came in and said he insisted that the machine be able to pick up whatever was on his floor-he was a drywall man.The customer brought in a small handful of drywall screws-we know how hard and SHARP these are.The Riccar Radiance ate them!!The customer bought the machine-both Bill and I winced as the machine picked up the nails-but how long can it do this?One of my Riccar's had a problem-it was exchanged without problem-height control not working right.Riccar supplied me with a new and improved vac-no cost to me or its shipping.Riccar does give excellent customer service!I also have a Blue Riccar "Briiliance" machine.Mikes vac place has a Simplicity "Synergy" machine-has had a lot of demos-someday will see if I can get it at a nice price!The Riccar Tandem air machines can sure PACK their bags-the bag is smaller than on some machines-but it tandem air action packs those bags tight!The bag is a BRICK when you take it out!


Post# 244914 , Reply# 46   8/9/2013 at 20:32 (3,905 days old) by dressur ()        

I like the idea of two motors. Next time I go through Missouri I will stop at that museum and factory. If I can sell some stereos, I may get a simplicity something. I like canisters more than uprights. they have a blue canister. it is expensive though 1200 bucks. I can buy two Dysons for that price.


Forum Index:       Other Forums:                      



Comes to the Rescue!

Woops, Time to Check the Bag!!!
Either you need to change your vacuum bag or you forgot to LOG-IN?

Discuss-O-MAT Log-In



New Members
Click Here To Sign Up.



                     


automaticwasher.org home
Discuss-o-Mat Forums
Vintage Brochures, Service and Owners Manuals
Fun Vintage Washer Ephemera
See It Wash!
Video Downloads
Audio Downloads
Picture of the Day
Patent of the Day
Photos of our Collections
The Old Aberdeen Farm
Vintage Service Manuals
Vintage washer/dryer/dishwasher to sell?
Technical/service questions?
Looking for Parts?
Website related questions?
Digital Millennium Copyright Act Policy
Our Privacy Policy