Thread Number: 14550
Royal wide path or kirby generation?
[Down to Last]

Vacuumland's exclusive eBay Watch:
scroll >>> for more items --- [As an eBay Partner, eBay may compensate vacuumland.org if you make a purchase using any link to eBay on this page]
Post# 154016   10/3/2011 at 00:13 (4,581 days old) by thissucks ()        

Ok, i need a paper bagged vac, i have a kirby omega that i love, but its driving my father and brother's alergies crazy.

so it gives me a reason to buy another vac!

anyhow i want a wide-path 18" royal or a self propelled kirby, they are simmilar machines but im trying to figure out what machine will clean better.

also does the royal's "coushionaire" work well on medium pile carpet?

(i know i can retro fit kirby but... i can get another vac :P )
all will be used or rebuilt.

also how does sanitair's 16" model stack up (would have to change bag)


Post# 154022 , Reply# 1   10/3/2011 at 01:38 (4,581 days old) by twocvbloke ()        

In general, Widetrack models tend to have poor airflow at the nozzle, as they have a wider than normal nozzle to try and evenly spread out the suction down onto the carpet and get the air to flow through it, so, rather than going for widetrack models, go for the standard models for a more thorough job... :)

Personally I'd get a Sanitaire, upgrade it to use the Eureka Filtrete ST bags (just requires a filltube known as the "Dirt Tube & Overmold Assy., see link), and there you go, sorted... :)

(It's funny, I forgot that the address for that site with the filltube was very similar to this site! Doesn't have a pic of the filltube, but it's the right one!)



CLICK HERE TO GO TO twocvbloke's LINK


Post# 154025 , Reply# 2   10/3/2011 at 05:39 (4,581 days old) by kirbymodel2c (Nottingham, England)        
Wellllll

kirbymodel2c's profile picture
Hi. Well personally I'd go for a G series Kirby. G5 Gsix onwards. Esp with you already having a Kirby Omega...
I do like the Royal Everlast series vacs. Of which I own the Royal Everlast 8300 Which I would go for over the 18inch royal.

Why not try to test one of each in person and see which one you like.
What's right for one person isn't for someone else.

I'm sure you will hear lots of opinions but trying a vac in person is the best way to go.

Hope this helps.

James:o)


Post# 154029 , Reply# 3   10/3/2011 at 06:43 (4,581 days old) by tolivac (Greenville,NC)        

The 18" Royals work fine for me-better than other 18" vacuums.However Kirby is still better.

Post# 154037 , Reply# 4   10/3/2011 at 08:29 (4,581 days old) by thissucks ()        

i have a standard size dump cup sanitair commercial and am suprized how it pulls up the nap (single row vibra-groomer) as twocvbloke mentioned his opinion. it would be a interesting machine to have, im sure the vibra-groomer would be crazy loud on this one.

still undecided, i know a 10amp royal has 124CFM and the widetrack is only 2inches wider than kirby and kirby has 105CFM. im still amazed how much suction this omega has running 4.5 amps. the sanitair is simple as can be.
i hate decisions.

i also made the mistake of buying a single row for the omega instead of double...


Post# 154051 , Reply# 5   10/3/2011 at 13:21 (4,581 days old) by scvacuumguy (SC)        

scvacuumguy's profile picture
Go to a vacuum cleaner store. Only they can provide the seasoned expert advice and maybe even give you a machine to take home and try.

Post# 154055 , Reply# 6   10/3/2011 at 14:11 (4,581 days old) by kirbymodel2c (Nottingham, England)        
Oh

kirbymodel2c's profile picture
Oh but just remember people in vac shops can be hit and miss. Some know what there talking about some talk out of there....Or only want to sell you what they stock. I know from past experience.Esp when I was younger. I'm sure by now you know who you can trust in your area. Just remember opinions are only opinions once you try each vac for yourself then go on from there..
Then look out for what you want at the right price for you...:o)

Let use know what you go for. Ohhh and take a pic of it.

James:o)


Post# 154056 , Reply# 7   10/3/2011 at 14:15 (4,581 days old) by Trebor ()        
The Royal handle...

with its three locking positions makes it easy to use it to vacuum couch cushions and arms, stair treads, and mattresses without hooking up a hose or getting out a canister. It is much lighter than the Kirby.

Post# 154064 , Reply# 8   10/3/2011 at 15:33 (4,581 days old) by gsheen (Cape Town South Africa)        

gsheen's profile picture

Will seen you collect vacuums hy not buy all three??? and use one for each part of the house, personally I do not like g series Kirby's , I have two sentria's I am trying to get rid of , I prefer a legend or heritage 11, I would take either a royal 18" or a sanitaire over a G series but that's just my feelings, best to go to a vac shop you can trust and try out all three, That's what I tell my customers , try it out then you will know if you like it, You wouldn't buy a new car before you tried it out would you.

Gareth 


Post# 154085 , Reply# 9   10/3/2011 at 18:57 (4,580 days old) by thissucks ()        

i work for a vac shop and i still dont know!

i have owned a regular 8.7 amp 12" royal and it worked well, it had a worn brush from day one. ive always wanted a 18" model but i would have to make a franken vac to get one (unless one of you folks have one to sell)

i WOULD buy all three but A- i have little money, B- i need to avoid getting bit by the bug because i already have 12 antique fans and would run out of room!



Post# 154087 , Reply# 10   10/3/2011 at 19:12 (4,580 days old) by broomvac (N/A)        
Kirby G series...

broomvac's profile picture
...is most likely the best way to go, especially since you are already on the Kirby bandwagon.

The Royals slightly out clean the Kirbys, but the Kirbys are all around more user friendly, have more options and good attachments (unlike Royal), and have better filtration. Not to mention the fact the tech drive is AWESOME!

New Royals are hideously loud anyways.

As for Sanitaires, I recommend you get anything without a shake out bag or a dirt cup (ESPECIALLY THE DIRT CUP ONES! They leak dust like a SIEVE!) All the other Sanitaires are great for allergy-free filtration, and on good days, can out clean either the Kirby or the Royal.


Post# 154088 , Reply# 11   10/3/2011 at 19:16 (4,580 days old) by thissucks ()        

anyone have any vacs mentioned willing to sell?

Post# 154389 , Reply# 12   10/6/2011 at 21:30 (4,577 days old) by thissucks ()        

ok, i found a motor brush end-bell (plastic bearing/brush holder) some gaskets, a new brushroll, plate and used wide-track front assembly.

franken vac is complete! it picks up and grooms as good as the normal nossle, slightly less suction, but enough to pick up the carpet and suck up a piece of paper with 1/4 of the nossle.

what suprized me the most is that it moves so eaisily, even more so with the huge brush.

it just plain looks cool :)
by the way its a model 2000 8.7A green with a serial of 93**** what year is it made?


Post# 154524 , Reply# 13   10/8/2011 at 08:41 (4,576 days old) by KirbyClassicIII (Milwaukie, Oregon)        
thissucks

kirbyclassiciii's profile picture
A Royal model 2000 upright would be made between 1995-2001. Prior to that there was the 5.0 amp model 882, produced from 1991-95, with the same green bag and green/grey trim.

Do you really think that a 6.0 amp model 618 or 680 series, in the 18" wide-track category, would perform well (the 618 was made from 1985-87, and the 680 series from 1987-90, except for 681 and 683 from 1989-90)? The same would go for the 7.0 amp 690 series (and the 6.0 amp 380 series) produced between 1990-95.

~Ben


Post# 154526 , Reply# 14   10/8/2011 at 09:05 (4,576 days old) by thissucks ()        

seeing the volume of the bell (which is very small compared to even kirby) and the efficentcy of the fan, i would say with even a 6A vac it would do just fine.

i would suspect a slight drop in suction, however most royal already have too much suction in the first place (two clicks on the toe adjust makes it suck up the carpet)

on mine i can still pick things up on the side of the nossle without getting close to them. it also gets super easy to push.

ps. the original vac the assembly was from was 7.0 amps i think.


Post# 154608 , Reply# 15   10/9/2011 at 02:38 (4,575 days old) by tolivac (Greenville,NC)        

Both of my 18" Royals work GREAT-better than the Sanitaire wide sweeps I have.but not quite as good as my 24" Powerflite.

Post# 154629 , Reply# 16   10/9/2011 at 06:58 (4,575 days old) by KirbyClassicIII (Milwaukie, Oregon)        

kirbyclassiciii's profile picture
All of the 6.0A 18" wide-track Royals, with the exception of the 380 series (as these were made after 1990), used a 6-bladed fan (the 680 series was, as I already mentioned, produced from 1987-90; Royal first used 9-bladed fans on their metal products beginning April 1990).

So that brings me to ask you: what would the performance of any of the 1985-90 Royal 18" wide-track models be (with the 6-blade impeller fan), compared to all those 9-bladed fan-equipped wide-track Royals made since April 1990?

~Ben


Post# 154919 , Reply# 17   10/10/2011 at 21:45 (4,573 days old) by thissucks ()        

im unfamiliar with 6 bladed royals ben.

i know that number of blades isnt everything, alot is pitch, engineering and RPM.

i also know amps are not everything also.

in short i dont know, but i would think 6 amps and 6 blades is enough to work well enough.


Post# 155005 , Reply# 18   10/11/2011 at 11:42 (4,573 days old) by Sablekid ()        

I have a Royal widepath, a standard Everlast, and a G5

 

Hands down G5....but the standard Royal comes pretty darn close, but the widepath is a no go.....Great for sort pile commercial carpets, but not for the standard household.


Post# 155129 , Reply# 19   10/12/2011 at 11:21 (4,572 days old) by thissucks ()        

the wide track works great in my house, its dense carpet though, wouldnt want to use it on shag. pulls up the nap nicley.

i still want a G3


Post# 155237 , Reply# 20   10/13/2011 at 04:55 (4,571 days old) by tolivac (Greenville,NC)        

I have used my Royal widecleans in my place-has deep cut pile carpet-they work really well-not as good as the Kirby G types-but better than the equivelaent Sanitaire model.I have picked up all types of debris with the Royals-I do think it is one of the only widesweeps that do well.My Monster Powerflite is another.24" sweep for that one.

Post# 155362 , Reply# 21   10/13/2011 at 23:54 (4,570 days old) by thissucks ()        

8.7 amps of power is plenty to do some really deep cleaning , its odd because the way it grooms the carpet it looks at first like its not doing a good job, but its because there are far less wheel/nossle marks, i ran both the kirby and sanitair over the freshly royal cleaned carpet and they are unable to do a better job bringing up the nap.

i would love to do a REAL test for deep cleaning, but im sure its about the same.

also, it doesnt feel like its sucking up the carpet because the huge brush roll pulls it along but sure enough it pulls the carpet off the ground 18 inches at a time!

kirby is really hard to beat, im still looking for a G-3 my fave G series i love the prototype look :)


Post# 155372 , Reply# 22   10/14/2011 at 03:08 (4,570 days old) by tolivac (Greenville,NC)        

I can to agree-Kirby is hard to beat.The Royal widesweep is one of the only widesweeps that works for me.I have two-a brand new one and an older one that I bought from a former vac place-The owner of the former vac shop(Vacuum Cleaner Hospital) died-but when his shop was operating-got several vacs from him at good prices-repaired machines that owners left for more than 30days.That is how I got one of my 18" Royals-it has the grey cloth dump bag-and a plain nozzle plug.


Forum Index:       Other Forums:                      



Comes to the Rescue!

Woops, Time to Check the Bag!!!
Either you need to change your vacuum bag or you forgot to LOG-IN?

Discuss-O-MAT Log-In



New Members
Click Here To Sign Up.



                     


automaticwasher.org home
Discuss-o-Mat Forums
Vintage Brochures, Service and Owners Manuals
Fun Vintage Washer Ephemera
See It Wash!
Video Downloads
Audio Downloads
Picture of the Day
Patent of the Day
Photos of our Collections
The Old Aberdeen Farm
Vintage Service Manuals
Vintage washer/dryer/dishwasher to sell?
Technical/service questions?
Looking for Parts?
Website related questions?
Digital Millennium Copyright Act Policy
Our Privacy Policy