Thread Number: 13708
Clean.....or much cleaner
[Down to Last]

Vacuumland's exclusive eBay Watch:
scroll >>> for more items --- [As an eBay Partner, eBay may compensate vacuumland.org if you make a purchase using any link to eBay on this page]
Post# 145381   7/31/2011 at 17:01 (4,650 days old) by vacu-finder ()        

I have read many posts on this site about cleaning performance.
Just like to add my 2 bits worth on Cleaning performance of different types of Vacuums, models, makes and what have you. This Vacuum works better than this one...etc....etc....etc......
Ok....so a good running vacuum will clean well providing the brush roll is satisfactory and the bag is not totally full as this does reduce suction power.

Case in point I used a small 7amp upright with barely 50 inches of pull at the end of the hose. Apartments were wall to wall carpet from one end to the other.
On 2 ocassions I used a commercial carpet cleaner made by Carpet Express, they have ton's of power and do a fantastic job of cleaning.
First time there was quite a bit of crud, that was before I started using the tiny 7amp Vacuum.......A year and half later I was amazed that the carpet was barley dirty after using the carpet cleaner.. This is after walking with shoes on after hiking trails, working in dirty shops.......etc.......etc.....and every day living.

This tells me that it is not necessarily what Vacuum you use, but how you use that Vacuum. There is a better way to Vacuum..!
Give me your take on this, would like to hear some other opinions.


Post# 145387 , Reply# 1   7/31/2011 at 18:31 (4,650 days old) by Trebor ()        
You are so right!

The older Royals and Hoovers and Kirbys were much less than 7amps. Part of the issue is filtration. The old sateen bags leaked like sieves, but kept the air flowing. Paper bags restrict the airflow quickly. Now the polyester electrostatic material used in top of the line bags offer high airflow and high filtration as the bag fills.

A good belt, and a clean, properly adjusted brushroll contribute to effective cleaning performance, as does slow, methodical coverage of the carpet, with repetitive coverage of the heavily trafficked areas.

Yes, the three B's belt bag, brush are the keys to maintaining performance,actually achieving effective cleaning is done by regular and thorough use of the vacuum cleaner.


Post# 145390 , Reply# 2   7/31/2011 at 20:09 (4,650 days old) by sanitairered (Michigan)        

sanitairered's profile picture
What kind of 7 amp vacuum do you have?
They may clean well for the time, but their filtration is horrible. I would rather have a 12 amp vacuum that not only picks up lots of dirt and dust, but holds it in too! After all, the reason you vacuum your house is to clean it, right? The 50 year old kirby might pick up lots of dirt, but if it blows it right back in the air, what's the point of cleaning? My two cents.



Post# 145391 , Reply# 3   7/31/2011 at 20:17 (4,650 days old) by Trebor ()        
Apparently...

you missed this sentence in my post

"Now the polyester electrostatic material used in top of the line bags offer high airflow and high filtration as the bag fills."

Amps have little to do with the ability to clean carpet as history has proved. Effective nozzle deign, and bag, belt and brush are more important. Lots of 12 amp vacuums that don't clean well at all have been built. The Royal metal uprightts are 7 and 8 amps


Post# 145394 , Reply# 4   7/31/2011 at 20:32 (4,650 days old) by sanitairered (Michigan)        

sanitairered's profile picture
That wasn't directed at you Trebor, it was more of a response to the original post. vacu-finder said 'give me your take on this' and I did. I agree with most of what you're saying, though.

Post# 145408 , Reply# 5   7/31/2011 at 21:46 (4,650 days old) by suckolux (Yuba City, CA)        

suckolux's profile picture
And , lets not forget, it never all comes up! My Dyson dc 18 is not a deep cleaner, but it always finds missed bits! The bin does not lie.

Post# 145439 , Reply# 6   8/1/2011 at 06:47 (4,649 days old) by KirbyLover (Louisville Kentucky )        

I would like to see a modern version of a Kirby 500 series that has 3 or 4 amps but modern bag/filtration and improved nozzle design. It's smaller than the Gen2 or G-series Kirbys so it doesn't need 6-7 amps (or whatever they are exactly).

On one of the facebook pages someone mentioned using a Rainbow after vacuuming with their Sentria and the Rainbow pulls lots of dirt into the water. I'd like to try that myself, except for the fact that I just have a big area rug upstairs (new) and my basement is 40+ year old thin carpet that will never be totally clean (needs to be replaced).

Also with Dysons the dirt "fluffs up" making it look like there is more than there is. In a Kirby it gets packed in the bottom of the bag which you can tell by lifting it from the bottom and feeling the weight. (Not criticizing anything about the Dyson cleaning ability, just sayin')


Post# 145455 , Reply# 7   8/1/2011 at 10:28 (4,649 days old) by vacu-finder ()        

I use a Panasonic upright 7 amp. The motor pre filter I'm using is a micro fit which is much better than the original foam piece, and multilayered bags.

Yes I do agree a more powerfull machine will pull up more. The dysons seem to lack the power especially when they start gewtting full


Post# 145457 , Reply# 8   8/1/2011 at 10:40 (4,649 days old) by vacu-finder ()        

Oooops. Forgot to mention Amps. The older Elctrolux's were only about 7-8 maps but had really good power. A central vac has around 12amp's operating and 14amp's at full draw. But a central vac has the water lift and flow that conventional Vacuums do not.
The Panasonic is only a single stage motor. I guess the point I'm trying to make is not all Vac's are not created equal, and the true test of performance is more like flow, volume of Air.


Post# 145460 , Reply# 9   8/1/2011 at 11:10 (4,649 days old) by sanitairered (Michigan)        
Two things..

sanitairered's profile picture
'The dysons seem to lack the power especially when they start gewtting full'

Dyson vacuum cleaners don't lose suction as they fill up, and it wouldn't matter if they were full or empty, they still have more than enough power to thoroughly clean a carpet.


Post# 145486 , Reply# 10   8/1/2011 at 14:31 (4,649 days old) by vacu-finder ()        

......:)

Post# 145602 , Reply# 11   8/2/2011 at 01:40 (4,648 days old) by tolivac (Greenville,NC)        

Central vacuum-at the canister outlet-most powerful.for the hose inlets in the house-less powerful-remember the unit has to pull thru all of that plumbing!Dyson filters can CLOG causing loss of suction or airflow.why do they have you clean or replace it?cyclones cannot filter out fine dust and dirt.Dealt with large versions in woodshops.those had baghouse filters on them.and of course the bin under the main cyclone to catch the large peices.Sanding dust goes to the baghouse filters.A lever was provided to allow you to shake them to get the fine dust into a trashbarrel or bin.

Post# 145610 , Reply# 12   8/2/2011 at 06:47 (4,648 days old) by KirbyLover (Louisville Kentucky )        
central vacs

How much power do they use? Do they run on 110V or 220V?

Post# 145638 , Reply# 13   8/2/2011 at 13:25 (4,648 days old) by suckolux (Yuba City, CA)        

suckolux's profile picture
My cyclones filter it out just fine! never any material on my washable filter, even after cleaning the whole apt from hardwood floor sanding! Nothing. Maybe they do not all work that way though.

Post# 145644 , Reply# 14   8/2/2011 at 14:19 (4,648 days old) by sanitairered (Michigan)        

sanitairered's profile picture
Yeah there's nothing in my filter either. The cyclones filter everything out just fine for me..

Post# 145650 , Reply# 15   8/2/2011 at 16:19 (4,648 days old) by kenkart ()        
Amps...

Dont mean much to me, a 535 watt Lux G is hard to beat, and a Filter Queen is darn near unbeatable, and they dont draw anywhere near 10 amps! all amps are is something to sell people on!...my 2 cents worth..LOL!

Post# 145701 , Reply# 16   8/3/2011 at 02:47 (4,647 days old) by tolivac (Greenville,NC)        

the filter in my Dyson DC07-came from the Kirby trade in pile-was encrusted with fine dirt and dog smell.Went to Best Buy and just bought a new one.Central vacuums can be had to run on 120v or 220V depending on the size of the central unit.Some commercial-institutional ones can run from 208-230V 3 phase.most household central vacuums run from 120V-15A or 20A.

Post# 145708 , Reply# 17   8/3/2011 at 07:03 (4,647 days old) by KirbyLover (Louisville Kentucky )        

Back to the original topic..

I wonder how people REALLY know how clean their carpet it? Do they use test strips, vacuum then clean out the vac and put a new bag in, reclean and cut the bag open? Or do they just get on their hands and needs and look at the carpet?

Do you think that some vacs may have higher suction and pull certain kinds of dirt from the carpet, whereas another vac with a better brushroll may pull out pet hair etc and other different kinds of dirt better?

I think Trebor nailed it on the head with the "3 B's". I do wonder if a 12amp Kirby would rip the carpet out of the floor though. ;)


Post# 145834 , Reply# 18   8/4/2011 at 02:52 (4,646 days old) by tolivac (Greenville,NC)        

A 12A Kirby would be interesting.Would be a beast of a vacuum!

Post# 145957 , Reply# 19   8/5/2011 at 15:55 (4,645 days old) by vacu-finder ()        

The deal with amperage. I know that is just a sales pitch. When you work on Vacuums and take a look at a lot of motors you will see those tiny single stage motors that pull 12 amps. They scream like a banshee..but they do not have the airflow. Cental Vacs accomplish this by having multiple stages and huge motors. I.E. 550 Airwatts should be good for about 3500q.ft. but yes depending on how many inlets and feet of pipe, elbows etc...
Like Kirbys for there great strenght, durability and will outlast my lifetime no prob!


Post# 146009 , Reply# 20   8/6/2011 at 03:05 (4,644 days old) by tolivac (Greenville,NC)        

The NSS M1 motor is LARGE-and can draw 11-12A it runs COOL and at a lower speed.It turns a fan that is close to 8" in diameter.-and it has large, thick, blades.But keep in mind when someone says "12A motor" that means the max power the motor draws during tests in a lab before the motor overheats or flies apart.12A is the max cont power the motor can draw.In a vacuum it is considerbly less.Esp if the motor only turns suction fans.If it turns the brushroll-that loads it more.

Post# 148732 , Reply# 21   8/25/2011 at 11:13 (4,625 days old) by gsheen (Cape Town South Africa)        
dyson filters

gsheen's profile picture
"Dyson filters can CLOG causing loss of suction or airflow.why do they have you clean or replace it?"

Dyson filters clog when the users don't follow the instructions. If you over fill the machine past the max mark the filter will get dirty,

As I sell & serviice them in our shop I always like to test them, I have emptied my machine everytime it gets to the max mark no later and on purpose havn't washed my filter in over 3 years , it hardly has any dust on it.

Most customers don't even know they have a filter
I had a customer move to SA from the Uk and brought her dc04 to us complaining of poor suction, when I asked her when last she cleaned the filter she looked suprised and said she didn; know it had one, the machine was 10 years old



The industrial cyclones used in woodshops are positive cyclones , if you read dysons book this is what took hime so long to develope , the cyclone in a dyson is a positive and negitave cyclone , nothing at all like the industrial ones.


Post# 148788 , Reply# 22   8/25/2011 at 21:23 (4,625 days old) by Blackheart (North Dakota)        
Dysons

blackheart's profile picture
They don't lose suction they do lose airflow though, when everything is fully clean it can pull a 1.5 on the baird guage and when it's dirty it doesn't pull anything. I feel that the air path is too complex for air to flow freely. I have the DC-17 which has the root separators. I typically empty it after each use or two but i still have this feeling that fine dust may be coating the insides of the cyclones. Just my two cents on it.

Post# 148837 , Reply# 23   8/26/2011 at 02:43 (4,624 days old) by tolivac (Greenville,NC)        

In dustrial cyclones can be either positive-fan blows into the cyclone system-the old high school woodshop-which meant EVERYTHING went thru the suction fan BEFORE the cyclone.We loved to toss woodblocks into the unused suction openings on the system-you blocked them when the other machines in use-anyway loved the CLANG as the wood peices went thru the fan turned by a 5Hp 3Ph motor.You then heard the PEICES rattling around and around in the cyclone before dropping into the waste bin.Now for the NEW high school woodshop-the cyclone in that one could be NEGATIVE-the cyclone was BEFORE the suction fan.the discharge of the fan blew into a baghouse type filter.another 5Hp fan.so a woodblock would rattle down that cyclone INTACT and fall into the bin.In both systems the fine dust-like from sanders,bandsaws and scrollsaws-would go into the baghouse filter on both.Never saw the fan in the direct air system-would have to imagine it would be pretty massive to withstand the inpact of the wood blocks.and would think the fan would get loaded from fine dust.I was one of the folks that emptied and tended these units.Was interesting and dusty duty-emptied after each shop class-for fire safety.and no metal or rags allowed in those systems-those could react with the sawdust and cause a fire.Torit,I vaguely beleive was the maker of one of them.New unit)old one-unknown.and for the Dyson vacuums-many users just don't understand it is a dump bin vacuum-like a dump bag vacuum,it has to be emptied after each use.That prolongs filter and dump bag life.Many users treat the Dyson and other dump bin,bag vacuums like a paper bag vacuum.they dump it when it is packed.I have looked into the cyclones of my Dyson vacs-yes they get coated with fine dust.Probably static attraction of the plastic-don't have this with grounded metal cyclones.

Post# 148847 , Reply# 24   8/26/2011 at 05:55 (4,624 days old) by gsheen (Cape Town South Africa)        

gsheen's profile picture
the cyclones do get a fine coat of dust on them , when we service them we strip the cyclones down and wash them out, on some of the older model dc08's and o7's the cylone can actually clog when they are over filled to many times .we clean them out and they are as good as new again. the newer 14,and other models have a better cylone system that is very difficult to clog , though some customers do manage it but then they are very special :)

Post# 149494 , Reply# 25   8/29/2011 at 22:28 (4,621 days old) by vacu-finder ()        

Just quoting you here Blackheart...
You wrote...

They don't lose suction they do lose airflow. I feel that the air path is too complex for air to flow freely. I have the DC-17 which has the root separators. I typically empty it after each use or two but i still have this feeling that fine dust may be coating the insides of the cyclones. Just my two cents on it.
=============================================================================

Tell me what fun is it when you Empty the dirt bin after every cleaning, does not make sense. And how many people actually do that.?
You also mention that the Air flow thru the Dyson is to complex to flow Freely.
I wondered about that when i first laid my eyes on the Dyson.
Every thing is coming together now..:)




Post# 149531 , Reply# 26   8/30/2011 at 08:17 (4,620 days old) by Blackheart (North Dakota)        

blackheart's profile picture
I doubt the typical user does, i do it cause while i do like to watch the dirt collect i do not like to look at it sitting there so i empty it out, i'm not a fan of the baffles in the dust cup though i prefer to watch it spin...i never really understood the point of those

Post# 149553 , Reply# 27   8/30/2011 at 09:23 (4,620 days old) by gsheen (Cape Town South Africa)        

gsheen's profile picture
The baffels in the dust cup are to stop the dirt spinning up the side and cloging the cyclone especially on the smaller capacity machines.


Post# 149555 , Reply# 28   8/30/2011 at 09:28 (4,620 days old) by gsheen (Cape Town South Africa)        
air flow

gsheen's profile picture
The cyclones on a dyson increase the air flow by making the air spin faster.

when checked it on the airflow meter these machine measure allot more that their competitors.wit or with out bags.
Only the dirty air ( I hate that word makes it sound bad )have more air flow at the cleaner head


Post# 149647 , Reply# 29   8/30/2011 at 20:47 (4,620 days old) by Blackheart (North Dakota)        

blackheart's profile picture
Strange you and i get completely different results, in terms of airflow the Dyson is one of my weaker machines it pulls a 1.5 on a Baird airflow meter. the only machines that i have that pull less are my tristar MG2 and my compact saniataire thingy. I've tested some of my other machine and if i recall my Electrolux Silverado pulled about a 3 with a dirty bag and about 4.5 with a clean one. what was really surprising was my little Riccar canister, which is no longer mine, had the most airflow at about a 6 maybe even 7. My kirby G6 at the end of the hose pulls about a 6.5 and at the motor housing on low speed pulls a 10, I"m going to do some re-testing as i lost my chart.

Post# 149681 , Reply# 30   8/31/2011 at 01:05 (4,620 days old) by gsheen (Cape Town South Africa)        

gsheen's profile picture
yes but I am compairing it to normal vacuums not Kirby's.

I am also not testing it at the end of the hose but at the brush bar , I have a huge test rig that we use to measure the air flow and lift of a vacuum on the carpet.

Also remember I'm 220volt , I have noticed that thier is a slight suction differance between the 220 volt motors and the 110volt.( we get 110 volt in for conversions from people moving to SA)

what is also dirfferant is the noise level, the 110v machines are much noiser.

I have a little aeg( what you guys now call electrolux ) that has huge suction its unreal but it almost cracks its top every time you close up suction.

I'll find my charts awell to give you the right figures.



Forum Index:       Other Forums:                      



Comes to the Rescue!

Woops, Time to Check the Bag!!!
Either you need to change your vacuum bag or you forgot to LOG-IN?

Discuss-O-MAT Log-In



New Members
Click Here To Sign Up.



                     


automaticwasher.org home
Discuss-o-Mat Forums
Vintage Brochures, Service and Owners Manuals
Fun Vintage Washer Ephemera
See It Wash!
Video Downloads
Audio Downloads
Picture of the Day
Patent of the Day
Photos of our Collections
The Old Aberdeen Farm
Vintage Service Manuals
Vintage washer/dryer/dishwasher to sell?
Technical/service questions?
Looking for Parts?
Website related questions?
Digital Millennium Copyright Act Policy
Our Privacy Policy